Peer Review Process

JIKI – Journal of Interdisciplinary Knowledge and Innovation implements a rigorous peer-review process to ensure the quality, originality, academic integrity, and relevance of all manuscripts submitted for publication. The review process is conducted through the following stages:

  1. Initial Editorial Screening
    All manuscripts submitted by authors undergo an initial screening by the editorial team. At this stage, the editors assess the manuscript's alignment with the journal's aims and scope, compliance with the prescribed manuscript template and formatting requirements, and its overall suitability for further consideration. Throughout this stage, the editors maintain communication with the authors regarding whether the manuscript is suitable to proceed to peer review or should be returned for revision before being considered for external review.
  2. Peer Review
    Manuscripts that successfully pass the initial editorial screening are assigned to two independent reviewers for a comprehensive assessment of their scholarly content. The journal employs a double-blind peer-review process, in which the identities of both the authors and reviewers are kept confidential throughout the review process.
  3. Review Criteria
    Reviewers evaluate manuscripts based on several key scholarly criteria, including originality and novelty, objectivity, methodological rigor, scientific significance and impact, clarity and validity of the conclusions, and the quality and relevance of the references. Reviewers may also provide specific comments and recommendations intended to strengthen the manuscript's academic quality.
  4. Reviewer Recommendations
    Based on their evaluation, reviewers may recommend that a manuscript be accepted, revised, or rejected. Where revisions are required, authors are expected to address the reviewers' comments carefully and provide appropriate responses to each substantive recommendation.
  5. Editorial Decision
    The final editorial decision is made by the editor after carefully considering the reviewers' recommendations, the quality of the revised manuscript where applicable, and the extent to which the submission meets the publication standards and requirements of JIKI – Journal of Interdisciplinary Knowledge and Innovation. The editor may request further revisions when necessary to ensure that the manuscript meets the journal's academic and ethical standards.
  6. Final Decision
    The editor's decision constitutes the final decision regarding the publication of the manuscript. The decision is made independently and in accordance with the journal's editorial policies, peer-review standards, and academic quality requirements.